Cooking with Toti
cookingwithtoti.com/recipes/classic-italian-tiramisu
Classic Italian Tiramisu (2 Versions)
The classic, in two safe versions — traditional raw-egg or tempered + heavy cream.
Serves
8–10
Time
30 min + 4 hr chill
Two trusted versions of classic tiramisu: the traditional raw-egg method and a no-raw-egg version with tempered yolks and heavy cream — both light, creamy, and dusted with cocoa.
Instructions
Version 1
- 1
Beat egg whites with a pinch of salt to soft peaks; slowly add ⅓ cup sugar and whip to stiff glossy peaks.
- 2
In another bowl, beat yolks with remaining ⅓ cup sugar until pale, thick, tripled in volume. Mix in vanilla and a splash of amaretto.
- 3
Mix cold mascarpone into the yolk mixture until smooth.
- 4
Fold meringue into mascarpone in 2–3 additions, bottom-to-top folds.
- 5
Mix cooled espresso with amaretto (optional rum/whiskey).
- 6
Layer: thin cream on the bottom → quick-dipped ladyfingers → cream → repeat → finish with cream.
- 7
Chill at least 4 hours (overnight best). Dust generously with cocoa before serving.
Version 2
- 1
Whisk yolks + sugar in a heatproof bowl. Over a gentle double boiler, whisk constantly 5–7 min until thick, pale, warm.
- 2
Off heat, stir in vanilla and a splash of amaretto. Let cool slightly.
- 3
Mix cold mascarpone into the yolk mixture until smooth.
- 4
Whip heavy cream with a pinch of salt to soft–medium peaks; fold into mascarpone gently.
- 5
Mix cooled espresso with amaretto.
- 6
Layer as above and chill at least 4 hours (overnight best). Dust with cocoa to serve.
Toti’s Tips
- ✓Fold the meringue into the mascarpone gently, working bottom to top, so you keep the air you whipped in — stirring too hard deflates it and leaves you with a dense, heavy filling instead of a light one.
- ✓Only dip the ladyfingers in and out of the espresso quickly. They're dry and porous, so a long soak turns them mushy and can make the whole cake soggy instead of holding distinct layers.
- ✓If Version 1's raw eggs are a concern for anyone eating it — pregnancy, young kids, elderly, or anyone with a weaker immune system — go with Version 2, where the yolks are cooked over a double boiler until safely thickened.
- ✓In Version 2, whisk the yolks and sugar constantly over the double boiler rather than letting them sit — constant motion keeps the eggs from scrambling as they cook to that thick, pale stage.
- ✓Chill the assembled tiramisu at least 4 hours, ideally overnight. This gives the cream time to firm up and the flavors from the coffee and amaretto time to soak through the ladyfingers.
- ✓Dust with cocoa right before serving rather than early — cocoa powder sitting on a moist cream layer for too long can start to clump or dissolve into the surface.
Storage
- •Refrigerator up to 3 days, covered.
Get my free e-book — 7 quick & easy dinners + 3 sweet bonus desserts
The weeknight dinners my kids actually ask for seconds of, plus the sweet treats — with photos from my own kitchen.
Free PDF · Unsubscribe anytime
